You Might Like

SECOND AMENDMENT WIN: Supreme Court Confirms 2A Applies to all Bearable Arms!


Supreme-Court-and-Guns

Dean WeingartenIn a historic, but extremely short unanimous opinion, the United States Supreme Court has confirmed that the Second Amendment applies “to all instruments that constitute bearable arms,”.  

As this is an enormous class of nearly all weapons, the decision is properly applied to knives and clubs, and nearly all firearms that have been sold in the United States. 

Nearly all types of firearms are more common than stun guns.

From NBC News:

But in an unsigned opinion, the U.S. Supreme Court Monday vacated that ruling. It said the Massachusetts court improperly found that Second Amendment protection applies only to weapons that were in common use at the time of the nation’s founding.

Referring to its landmark 2008 ruling on handguns in the home, the justices said the Second Amendment applies “to all instruments that constitute bearable arms,” even those not in existence at the time of the founding.

The unsigned opinion is very short.  It is sparse, as noted by justices Thomas and Alito.  Alito writes a much longer and more forceful opinion in concurrence.  It could, and should, have gone much further.  None the less, it is an enormous win for Second Amendment supporters, and it extends far beyond stun guns and Massachusetts.  Because the opinion is short, here is the unanimous opinion, without Justice Alito’s concurrence, which is at the link.

14-10078 Caetano v. Massachusetts(pdf) :

Cite as: 577 U. S. ____ (2016)
1
ALITO, J., concurring in judgment

SUPREME COURT OF THE UNITED STATES

JAIME CAETANO v. MASSACHUSETTS
ON PETITION FOR WRIT OF CERTIORARI TO THE SUPREME
JUDICIAL COURT OF MASSACHUSETTS

No. 14–10078.Decided March 21, 2016

PER CURIAM.

The Court has held that “the Second Amendment extends, prima facie, to all instruments that constitute bearable arms, even those that were not in existence at the time of the founding,” District of Columbia v. Heller, 554 U. S. 570, 582 (2008), and that this “Second Amendment right is fully applicable to the States,” McDonald v.Chicago, 561 U. S. 742, 750 (2010). In this case, the Supreme Judicial Court of Massachusetts upheld a Massachusetts law prohibiting the possession of stun guns after examining “whether a stun gun is the type of weapon contemplated by Congress in 1789 as being protected by the Second Amendment.” 470 Mass. 774, 777, 26 N. E. 3d 688, 691 (2015).

The court offered three explanations to support its holding that the Second Amendment does not extend to stun guns. First, the court explained that stun guns are not protected because they “were not in common use at the time of the Second Amendment’s enactment.” Id., at 781, 26 N. E. 3d, at 693. This is inconsistent with Heller’s clear statement that the Second Amendment “extends . . . to . . . arms . . . that were not in existence at the time of the founding.” 554 U. S., at 582.

The court next asked whether stun guns are “dangerous per se at common law and unusual,” 470 Mass., at 781, 26 N. E. 3d, at 694, in an attempt to apply one “important limitation on the right to keep and carry arms,” Heller, 554 U. S., at 627; see ibid. (referring to “the historical tradition of prohibiting the carrying of ‘dangerous and unusual weapons’ ”). In so doing, the court concluded that stun guns are “unusual” because they are “a thoroughly modern invention.” 470 Mass., at 781, 26 N. E. 3d, at 693–694. By equating “unusual” with “in common use at the time of the Second Amendment’s enactment,” the court’s second explanation is the same as the first; it is inconsistent with Heller for the same reason.

Finally, the court used “a contemporary lens” and found “nothing in the record to suggest that [stun guns] are readily adaptable to use in the military.” 470 Mass., at 781, 26 N. E. 3d, at 694. But Heller rejected the proposition “that only those weapons useful in warfare are protected.” 554 U. S., at 624–625.

For these three reasons, the explanation the Massachusetts court offered for upholding the law contradicts this Court’s precedent. Consequently, the petition for a writ of certiorari and the motion for leave to proceed in forma pauperis are granted. The judgment of the Supreme Judicial Court of Massachusetts is vacated, and the case is remanded for further proceedings not inconsistent with this opinion.

There is strong language in this opinion.  If 200,000 stun guns in the U.S. are “common”, it is hard to believe that 5 million AR-15s and millions of other semi-automatic rifles are “unusual”.

If stun guns are common and protected by the Second Amendment, then so are knives, clubs, and future weaponry.

The case lays to rest the idea that courts can simply say anything other than handguns are “uncommon” or “unusual” and are therefore exempt from Second Amendment protections.

This case will be cited far into the future.

 

About Dean Weingarten:

Dean Weingarten has been a peace officer, a military officer, was on the University of Wisconsin Pistol Team for four years, and was first certified to teach firearms safety in 1973. He taught the Arizona concealed carry course for fifteen years until the goal of constitutional carry was attained. He has degrees in meteorology and mining engineering, and recently retired from the Department of Defense after a 30 year career in Army Research, Development, Testing, and Evaluation.

©2016 by Dean Weingarten: Permission to share is granted when this notice and link are included. Link to Gun Watch

Previous Restaurant Patron Fells One Armed Robber & Scares Off Another, Dallas, TX
Next Guns at the Workplace, Things to Consider

42 Comments

  1. April 5, 2020

    generic cialis tadalafil http://genericalis.com/

  2. April 13, 2020

    Thank you.

    Youseful blog. Good post.

  3. April 14, 2020

    doctor7online.com

    SECOND AMENDMENT WIN: Supreme Court Confirms 2A Applies to all Bearable Arms! – Weapons Media

  4. else fly [url=https://amstyles.com/#]albuterol inhaler for sale
    generic[/url] best focus there negotiation generic albuterol inhaler lower context albuterol inhaler for sale generic
    somehow neck https://amstyles.com/

  5. generic viagra no prescription

    SECOND AMENDMENT WIN: Supreme Court Confirms 2A Applies to all Bearable Arms! – Weapons Media

  6. April 25, 2020

    viagra vs cialis

    SECOND AMENDMENT WIN: Supreme Court Confirms 2A Applies to all Bearable Arms! – Weapons Media

  7. May 18, 2020

    cheap viagra [url=https://www.genericviragacheap.com/]viagra without a doctor prescription[/url] generic viagra viagra without doctor prescription viagra

  8. May 19, 2020

    viagra online [url=https://zvigariageneric.com/]viagra generic[/url] generic viagra viagra online viagra

  9. May 19, 2020

    generic viagra [url=https://buyonlinewwwmen.com/]generic viagra[/url] viagra online viagra п»їviagra

  10. May 21, 2020

    viagra online [url=https://sexviagen.com/]viagra online[/url] generic viagra viagra viagra online

  11. May 21, 2020

    cialis [url=https://valcialisns.com/]cialis online[/url] online cialis cialis cialis online

  12. May 21, 2020

    online cialis [url=http://www.ciallisonline.com/]п»їcialis[/url] online cialis cialis generic cialis online

  13. May 22, 2020

    viagra [url=https://genericjojos.com/]cheap viagra[/url] viagra online generic viagra cheap viagra

  14. I am in truth divine along with your writing skills and likewise with
    the anatomical structure to your blog. Is that this a gainful case subject or did you custom-make it your mortal?
    Either room stoppage up the fantabulous senior high school timber
    writing, it’s rare to see a keen web log same this unmatched these
    years.. http://www.cialisles.com/

  15. May 23, 2020

    online cialis [url=http://pharmcilisa.com/]generic cialis[/url] cialis online online cialis cheap cialis

  16. May 23, 2020

    viagra generic [url=https://medyvirgaraonline.com/]buy viagra[/url] online viagra viagra viagra without doctor prescription

  17. May 24, 2020

    online cialis [url=https://cialisfw.com/]generic cialis[/url] п»їcialis п»їcialis generic cialis

  18. May 25, 2020

    cialis generic [url=http://genericcialls.com/]online cialis[/url] cialis online cialis online generic cialis

  19. May 25, 2020

    generic viagra [url=https://emtpartsstore.com/]buy viagra[/url] viagra online generic viagra buy viagra

  20. May 26, 2020

    cialis [url=https://cialishwzbm.com/]cialis online[/url] buy cialis buy cialis cialis online

  21. May 27, 2020

    cialis online [url=https://cialisovnnc.com/]cialis online[/url] generic cialis generic cialis cialis

  22. May 28, 2020

    viagra [url=https://cheapnowaaaa.com/]cheap viagra[/url] viagra viagra cheap viagra

  23. May 30, 2020

    generic viagra [url=https://canadianpharmacyfda.com/]viagra[/url] viagra generic viagra viagra online

  24. May 30, 2020

    viagra online [url=https://viagrapfhze.com/]viagra[/url] viagra online viagra online п»їviagra

  25. May 31, 2020

    viagra [url=https://viagraveikd.com/]п»їviagra[/url] п»їviagra viagra generic viagra

  26. May 31, 2020

    generic cialis [url=https://buycialensf.com/]cialis[/url] buy cialis buy cialis generic cialis

  27. June 7, 2020

    cialis [url=https://1cialisehds.com/]cialis[/url] cialis cialis cialis online

  28. June 10, 2020

    best essay services [url=https://essaywritingservicehgv.com/]write essay service[/url] mba essay review service cheap essay services essay writing service us

  29. June 10, 2020

    buy essay cheap [url=https://essayhelpeth.com/]essay help chat[/url] law essay help essayhelp the help essays

  30. June 13, 2020

    custom essay services [url=https://essaywritingservicevcr.com/]essays services[/url] essay writer service review write my essay service write my essay services

  31. JamesCycle
    June 14, 2020

    Знаете ли вы?
    Русские мечтали о шапке-невидимке, а древние греки — о кольце невидимости.
    Сын политика-пьяницы помог принять сухой закон в своей провинции.
    В роскошном болонском фонтане горожане стирали бельё и справляли нужду.
    Иногда для поддержки экономики деньги «разбрасывают с вертолёта».
    Подруга и последовательница Льва Толстого уже в детстве ходила босиком и отвергала нарядную одежду.

    [url=http://0pb8hx.com/]0PB8hX[/url]

  32. JamesCycle
    June 14, 2020

    Знаете ли вы?
    В роскошном болонском фонтане горожане стирали бельё и справляли нужду.
    Залётная птаха занесена в перечень птиц России спустя более полувека после открытия вида.
    Планета — глазное яблоко может быть пригодна для жизни в одних районах и непригодна в других.
    Подруга и последовательница Льва Толстого уже в детстве ходила босиком и отвергала нарядную одежду.
    Художник-карикатурист известен пародией на мунковский «Крик».

    [url=http://0pb8hx.com/]0PB8hX[/url]

  33. June 17, 2020

    cialis online [url=https://cialishwzbm.com/]cialis online[/url] cialis buy cialis online buy cialis online

  34. June 18, 2020

    how long to write a 5 page paper [url=https://termpapernfu.com/]term paper example[/url] paper layout paper stucture research paper layouts

  35. June 18, 2020

    dissertation sample [url=https://dissertationyjx.com/]dissertation database[/url] dissertation express dissertation length dissertation acknowledgements

  36. June 18, 2020

    write my paper for me free [url=https://writemypaperbuyefp.com/]write a paper online[/url] how to write a paper write my paper for me write my paper for me cheap

  37. June 19, 2020

    custom essay org [url=https://customessaywritersfz.com/]best essay writer[/url] essay writer program essay on old custom cheap essay writers

  38. June 21, 2020

    custom application essay [url=https://customessayiae.com/]custom written essay[/url] essays custom custom essays writing online custom essays

  39. June 21, 2020

    п»їviagra [url=https://usaerectionrx.com/]generic viagra[/url] viagra online generic viagra п»їviagra

  40. June 22, 2020

    viagra [url=https://xvirgaronline.com/]online viagra[/url] viagra online viagra viagra online

  41. June 22, 2020

    generic viagra [url=https://onlineviaqer.com/]viagra online[/url] generic viagra viagra online viagra online

  42. June 25, 2020

    viagra [url=https://sophiapharmsd.com/]viagra generic[/url] viagra sale generic viagra viagra

Leave a reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *